© 2022 WSHU
NPR News & Classical Music
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations

Vt.’s housing health & safety system didn’t protect farmworkers, so they created their own program

A photograph showing a small room, with a dirty stove in the foreground, a bunk bed in the background, and clothing, food and boxes crammed into many spaces.
Migrant Justice, Courtesy
/
This is the single room where three farmworkers used to live in Swanton. Through Milk With Dignity, a farmworker-created program that requires farm owners to meet certain housing and labor standards, the Swanton farm built new housing for its workers.

The front door to Javier’s house is at the top of two flights of stairs. He lives above a dairy barn in Addison County.

Puedes leer la versión en español, aquí.

We’re using a pseudonym for Javier. He’s worried about what his employer might do in response to speaking out about the conditions of his housing.

Inside, Javier gives me a tour. We start in the kitchen, where an ancient-looking air conditioning unit sits in the wall. Javier says the previous AC unit didn’t work properly for months this summer before his boss finally replaced it.

“It didn't work, just the air, like a fan … and it lasted around three months, or two,” Javier says.

English: A photograph of a dirty air conditioning unit set into a wall. Español: La foto de un aire acondicionado sucio puesto en la pared.
Elodie Reed
/
Vermont Public
This is the replacement air conditioner that Javier says his boss finally gave him and his roommates after an old AC unit stopped working properly for months during the summer.

In the bathroom, the toilet sometimes leaks into the kitchen area. Then there’s the shower. It has no shower head, just a bare pipe. Javier says the water sometimes comes out scalding. So he’ll use a bucket to mix it with cold water to bathe.

In Javier’s windowless bedroom, you can hear the sound of mooing cows.

“There are some cows down here that are going to give birth,” he says. “If they move, the house moves.”

When I ask Javier if he’s talked to his boss about his housing conditions, he says he has, with mixed results. In the meantime, Javier says he adapts, because he has to.

But living like this can be bad for your health. According to the World Health Organization, poor housing is connected with respiratory, cardiovascular and infectious diseases, injuries and mental illness.

Vermont's rental housing regulation

Javier is among the 2,000 or so people living in on-farm housing provided by their employers in Vermont, mostly on dairy farms. Employees live on site because they often lack transportation, and work long hours.

Because of the year-round, more-permanent nature of dairy production, a Department of Labor spokesperson told Vermont Public that the federal law intended to protect seasonal migrant workers — including their housing rights — does not apply to farmworkers like Javier.

Under Vermont law, however, farmworkers with employer-provided housing are guaranteed a safe, clean and habitable place to live. On-farm housing is covered by the state’s rental housing health code, which requires things like proper heating and ventilation, functional bathrooms and weather-tight rooms.

English: A photograph of the upper half of a room’s four walls and ceiling, all made of plywood, all windowless, and lit with a single lightbulb. Español: Una foto de las cuatro paredes y el techo de la mitad superior del cuarto, todas sin ventanas, e iluminadas con un solo foco.
Elodie Reed
/
Vermont Public
This is Javier’s bedroom at the Addison County farm where he works. He says the roof sometimes leaks water.

But Vermont Public found that no state agency tracks on-farm housing complaints.

Currently, rental housing health is overseen by the Department of Health. And it’s enforced by town and city health officers.

Meg McCarthy is with the Health Department. She says when health officers receive a complaint, they do an inspection and then set a deadline to fix the problem.

But she says there’s no specific process for how a health officer might check whether the problem is actually fixed.

“They might ask for, you know, receipts or an email or something to show that the violation has been corrected,” McCarthy says. “They may go out and do a follow-up inspection.”

And under this system, the state doesn’t know the nature or number of these complaints.

“It would kind of be a town-by-town question at this point,” McCarthy says. “I have not heard of many — if any — complaints about farmworker housing that have, you know, that have been raised up to me. That's not to say they don't happen.”

English: Two photographs stacked on top of each other. The top photo shows the top half of a shower, and where the shower head should be, is just a bare pipe. In the bottom photo, a large red bucket sits on the floor of a dirty shower. Español: Dos fotos puestas una sobre la otra. La foto superior muestra la parte superior de la mitad de la ducha, y donde se supone que debe ir ubicada la ducha, solo hay un simple tubo. En la foto inferior, una balde rojo grande se posa sobre el piso de la ducha sucia.
Elodie Reed
/
Vermont Public
Migrant Justice says its Milk With Dignity program has received 181 housing-related complaints since it began in 2017. Pictured here is a shower used by farmworkers in Addison County. The bucket is for when the water comes out scalding hot and has to be mixed with cold water in order to be used for bathing.

Under legislation passed last session, Vermont’s rental housing regulation will become more centralized. All complaints will go to the Department of Public Safety’s Division of Fire Safety.

Mike Desrochers is that division’s executive director. In an email to Vermont Public, he said people can make complaints to the system by email, phone or a fillable form. The new law still does not include a specific process for follow-up.

And in the past, Desrochers says he knows of very few fire safety complaints made specifically about on-farm housing. He says the Division of Fire Safety database doesn’t track complaints by type of residence, just by address.

Moving forward, Desrochers says the division does plan to include on-farm housing in its public education outreach.

But farmworker advocates say these existing systems don’t work for them.

 “So having access to those systems is not something that is known by the community,” says Marita Canedo, who is with Migrant Justice. She says making housing complaints to state agencies isn’t practical when many of the state’s dairy farmworkers speak Spanish as a first language.

“There are no staff that speak the language or will understand and answer a call in their language,” Canedo says.

Desrochers says the Division of Fire Safety will have both Spanish and French versions of its complaint form, and has access to interpreters when needed.

Farmworkers build their own system

While there is currently little interaction between Vermont agencies and workers living in on-farm housing, one government body has identified that there is a widespread problem.

In 2021, the Vermont Housing and Conservation Board released a report highlighting key issues with on-farm housing for workers, including overcrowding, fire hazards, lack of functioning appliances in kitchens and bathrooms, as well as improper ventilation.

The report says more than half of Vermont’s farmworker housing units are in need of repairs.

Migrant Justice is well aware of these challenges. The group says it has received 181 housing complaints through its Milk With Dignity program.

Up and running since 2017, it asks companies that sign on to pay a premium to the farms they source their dairy from. In exchange, the farms comply with a code of conduct, which includes providing safe and clean housing.

More from Vermont Public: How an annual soccer tournament brings together Vermont's farmworker community

Canedo says farmworkers created this enforcement program when the state’s mechanisms failed.

“We know unfortunately the capacity of the state, having people doing investigations in housing, it's lacking or there is no capacity,” she says. “Implementation of basic standards like fire extinguishers, smoke alarms, are not being seen.”

And Canedo says it’s designed by farmworkers, for farmworkers.

“It comes from the people directly affected,” she says. “So the workers created these standards in housing, they are living there day by day, so they know what they need.”

English: Two photos side by side, one showing a dirty old stove, the other showing a clean new stove. Español: Dos fotos, una junto a la otra. En una, se muestra una estufa vieja y sucia, y la otra muestra una estufa completamente nueva.
Migrant Justice, Courtesy
/
The before and after photos of the old stove and its replacement inside farmworker housing in Swanton.

Canedo coordinates the program and answers its tele ayuda support line.

“Most of the complaints come when the people are already gone from the farm,” she says. “Because of this fear of you know, you lose your job, you lose your housing situation.”

She says if the complaint comes from a farm that doesn’t want to make housing improvements, and is outside of the program, Migrant Justice tries to organize workers and protect them from being fired.

Canedo says in some cases, farm owners are more willing.

“We have seen in some cases that farm owners really want to change the situation, but they don't have the resources, or the space," she says.

How to move forward

For the 50 or so farms currently covered by Milk With Dignity, they either have to fix the problem, or potentially lose their premium payments and market for milk.

And workers on those farms do see real change. Like Anthony, a farmworker in Swanton. He says he used to live in a barn, in a single room with two other people, where they’d all sleep and eat.

But Migrant Justice says the farm has since used its premium money to build more housing. Anthony now lives in a new, clean, three-bedroom house. He says he can come home, relax, and disconnect from work.

English: A man in a black turtleneck, jeans and sandals sits on a bed in a clean-looking housing space. He’s looking right into the camera. Español: Un hombre usando un suéter negro con cuello de tortuga, jeans, y sandalias, se sienta sobre la cama en un espacio limpio. Él está viendo directamente a la cámara.
Migrant Justice, Courtesy
/
Through Milk With Dignity, Swanton farmworker Anthony went from sharing one dirty, cramped room with two other people to having his own bedroom in a brand new house.

“Pretty calm, relaxed, okay, life seems lighter than the one I had before,” Anthony says.

Farmworkers and their advocates say while Milk With Dignity is effective in improving on-farm housing conditions, it currently covers just 20% of Vermont's dairy industry. They say more businesses need to take part in order to reverse what they say are crisis conditions.

Ben & Jerry’s is the only company in the program. Migrant Justice is trying to get supermarket chain Hannaford to sign on, and eventually, it would also like state institutions that purchase and serve dairy to join.

For now, the organization says it is beginning to collaborate with the state. Migrant Justice recently helped refer farm owners to a new farmworker housing repair loan program overseen by the Vermont Housing and Conservation Board and administered by the Champlain Housing Trust.

That program had $500,000 to spend. In its first round, it received application requests for a total of $1.7 million.

You can find a Spanish version of this story here, which we produced in partnership with New Hampshire Public Radio.

Have questions, comments or tips? Send us a message or tweet producer/reporter Elodie Reed @elodie_reed.

Updated: November 1, 2022 at 5:22 PM EDT
This story has been updated to reflect that the Champlain Housing Trust administers the new farmworker housing repair loan program.
Corrected: October 31, 2022 at 10:20 AM EDT
This story has been updated to more accurately reflect how much of Vermont's dairy industry is covered by Milk With Dignity.
Elodie is a reporter and producer for Vermont Public. She previously worked as a multimedia journalist at the Concord Monitor, the St. Albans Messenger and the Monadnock Ledger-Transcript, and she's freelanced for The Atlantic, the Christian Science Monitor, the Berkshire Eagle and the Bennington Banner. In 2019, she earned her MFA in creative nonfiction writing from Southern New Hampshire University.